Oh for fuck's sake.
Emma Watson's speech at the UN.
Look, it's bliddy scary, putting your head above the pulpit, and for that I salute her. But before we crack open the Lady Grey and English muffins, Hollywood poster boys holding up homemade placards is so not the point.
We have to invite men not to be dicks now? We're extending an invitation not to be a dick? That's our plan for how to make feminism palatable?
Side note - why are we worried about feminism being palatable? More than a million women in Britain suffering domestic abuse a year isn't palatable. 400,000 (reported) sexual assaults. 85,000 (reported) rapes. These aren't numbers that slink down the throat as you swallow them whole. These are numbers that keep you up at night with fire in your belly and raging acid reflux. (Trigger warning: the metaphors are likely to get worse from here).
Why has the word feminism became an uncomfortable one? Because feminism is holding up a big shiny mirror to society and reflecting uncomfortable ideas like power and violence and oppression back at a world that would prefer to think of itself as having dealt with all that in the sixties.
And breathe.
Never mind asking men to take our hands like waifish debutantes, how about asking them to take their hands off for starters? If someone is holding me down and punching me in the face, I'm not inclined to wait for his RSVP to STOP BEING A DICK.
Yes, men are hurt by inequality between the genders, but not as much as women are.
That's how inequality works. And yes, it's uncomfortable.
Don't get me wrong - the show I keep banging on about looks at how one man's definition of being male wreaked misogynistic havoc on his sexual relationships. A feminist show about being a man - hoist me on my own petard why don't you? I couldn't agree more that confining men to stereotypes of what it is to be male forces those of us who are not male to interact with them in reductive ways. That said, Owen Jones' assertion that 'Men are being killed by our sexist society' made me want to kick things.
Again, not because he isn't right to link male suicide rates to 'oppressive expectations of manliness' which stop young men seeking help and talking about how they feel, but because there's a difference between deciding to take your own life and someone else beating you to death.
And before you hang me out to dry with the other 'old-school man-hating bra-burning feminists' of the pre-Watson era, YES, I agree that mens' 'decisions' are shaped by social and cultural forces… It's just that women also live in a world that slaps reductive gender expectations on us that instead of making it more likely that we'll kill ourselves, make it more likely we'll accept as 'normal' situations in which we're over-powered and over-ruled, paid less, sexually assaulted, punched in the face… killed.
You're right, awareness is a good thing. Projects like Everyday Sexism are a very good thing. Hell, if it helps demystify the potential for men to be feminists, then even a brand spanking new celebrity-endorsed hashtag can be a good thing.
#DontJustTweetItBeatIt
The culture has to change. That doesn't happen if you put a selfie on social media and then swan back onto a movie set where you are paid more than your female costars/outnumber females across both cast and crew/portray stories that perpetuate the stereotypes. And, lovely Emma, it doesn't change as a 'natural consequence' of men becoming 'free' of gender stereotypes. It's so much harder than that, and if you're the one giving up power, you're not going to enjoy it all the time.
Patriarchy has to start punching itself in the face, and that's going to hurt. The fuzzy feeling of doing the right thing might wear off when it means you're taking a pay cut, or having to share more unpaid domestic work, or sharing the time away from your career for child rearing or turning down work because that project/company/organisation support the misogynistic status quo.
But it's still worth doing, because we do all benefit from equality. This isn't an invitation, I'm just going to assume that if you're reading this, you're ready.
All the makings of a made up sense maker. Not made it yet, this could be the making of her.
Saturday, 27 September 2014
Tuesday, 8 July 2014
A few guidelines
Portrait of Ms Ruby May, Standing by Leena McCall
I'm on my back, I've assumed the position.
Soothing pan-Asian lift-music drifts over from the iPod by the door.
Deep breath. Tchah. Sharp breath out.
Me
Did you see that story about the
portrait of a woman Mall Galleries
moved out of sight because it
shows her pubes?
Beautician
[laughs]
No! That's ridiculous! Just move
your leg slightly there.
your leg slightly there.
Me
Yeah, apparently it's 'disgusting and
pornographic'.
Beautician
Kind of ironic.
Me
I know! Porn is one of the places
you're least likely to see pubic hair.
Beautician
Yeah. My women all do this for
themselves, rather than...but I
do think there's a trickle down
from porn to 'the Hollywood.'
themselves, rather than...but I
do think there's a trickle down
from porn to 'the Hollywood.'
Me
Mmhmm. I wonder how much of all
that 'we feel cleaner' shtick is
psychological.
Beautician
It's actually more hygienic to keep
the hair.
the hair.
Me
[raises plucked eyebrow]
I sometimes feel like if I was a
proper feminist I would go back,
that I should grow it back...
that I should grow it back...
Beautician
I think it's fine to have a full seventies,
but you should still trim it - I was at a
training thing and this woman had
a full seventies and it's just suddenly
- boing - and it's a bit 'woah'. And I'm
just thinking 'that poor man'.
but you should still trim it - I was at a
training thing and this woman had
a full seventies and it's just suddenly
- boing - and it's a bit 'woah'. And I'm
just thinking 'that poor man'.
I'm staring at the serene Buddha statue, wondering about our different uses of the word 'should'. I'm wary of sentences that contain the word 'should'. 'Should' is what someone else thinks. 'Should' is a truth handed down to you rather than lived experience.
Beautician
... and it turns out that the friend Cameron
Diaz told Graham Norton she'd pinned
to the bathroom floor and'clipped' was
Gwyneth Paltrow.
to the bathroom floor and'clipped' was
Gwyneth Paltrow.
Me
Really? That sounds a bit brutal...
Have you read Caitlin Moran's How
to be a Woman?
Beautician
Caitlin who? No.
Me
She's good on women making their
own calls about this stuff- There's
a really funny bit about sanitary
towels...
Beautician
I saw Cameron Diaz has got a new book
out about women learning to love
their bodies. So she's completely
contradicted herself. Do you want any
more off? I've just followed the guideline,
out about women learning to love
their bodies. So she's completely
contradicted herself. Do you want any
more off? I've just followed the guideline,
but we can make the strip thinner.
Me
No thanks, that's my line.
Wednesday, 2 July 2014
Monsters Inc
So Rolf Harris is the latest to be declared 'a monster'.
David Sillito reports for the BBC:
"During his trial prosecutors said Harris was a "Jekyll and Hyde" character who took advantage of his fame."
Jane Peel talks of Harris': 'Dark side revealed under court's spotlight'.
I find this gothic language unhelpful: it's another way of making abusers 'other', another way of pretending this sort of thing is down to a few objectionable individuals, rather than something our culture facilitates. It was the same with the Elliot Rodger case: a kid declares his hatred for women because not one of us had offered ourselves to him, and he goes out and shoots at people, killing six. However the news stories are of a 'virgin killer' (like that explains anything) or even more worryingly fixated on his asperges as a means of discounting the misogynistic intent of his attacks.
If you listen very carefully you can hear the thrumming bass line beneath this kind of reporting 'notallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmen...'
Thing is, it's much more terrifying than that: you don't have to be a monster to be an abuser, you just have to decide to do it.
On the other end of the spectrum we have Charles Saatchi, pictured throttling his then wife at a ritzy London restaurant, now hosting artistic depictions of said assault on his company's website: enacting that very capitalist tactic of absorbing the opposition in order to smother it. And if there's one thing Mr Saatchi knows, it's the role of buying and selling in defining an artefact's cultural worth.
I'm not for a second implying that the acts perpetrated by Harris, Rodger, Saatchi and their fellow abusers aren't monstrous, but I am also saying: 'nice' men harrass, groom, molest, hit, strangle, manipulate, assault: nice men rape.
I've been thinking a lot about shocking truths supposedly 'hidden' in plain sight. I've written a show that is partly about how we only see what we are pre-disposed to see. It's a show about how our misogynistic culture plays out in our intimate relationships. It's also a show about Pick up Artist forums. For the uninitiated: the Pick up Artist industry teaches men techniques and behaviours to employ in picking up women. Despite the fact that these techniques are often highly reductive, predatory and manipulative, PUAs are largely written off as losers who can't pick up girls (sad little monsters). These have spawned reactionary 'anti-PUA' sites which refute the notion that men should have to use techniques or behaviours to get sex from women: not because these techniques and behaviours are often highly reductive, predatory and manipulative, but because women are only good for etc etc (shouty scary monsters). Seen in this context Rodger's actions are the logical end game for misogyny.
'notallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmen...'
Recently a very wise and very dear friend accused me of making 'middle class' art. As I baulked at this over my g'n't it clarified something for me about where I'm positioning this piece, and the media's infinite ability to be shocked by revelations of another nice man we all trusted before putting him in with all the other monsters...
Discounting is an unconscious minimisation or exaggeration of circumstance, relating to the self, others or a shared reality.
There are four accumulative levels of discounting:
1) The existence of a problem: nice men don't rape
2) The significance of a problem: ok, nice men do rape but it doesn't affect me
3) The possibility of change: ok, nice men do rape, this is bad for everybody but what can we do, it's the way they're wired, or something.
4) Our personal ability to effect change: ok, nice men do rape, this is bad for everybody, the ability to decide what we do with who we are is what makes us human, so I'm going to...
My answer to that last one was to write my show.
I've had to graciously concede that I'm not making proletariat revolutionary art. In fact, it's worse than what my dear, wise friend suspected, I might even be making art for the ruling classes. I wonder whether the four levels of discounting are also mirrored in how to make 'revolutionary' art according to our class system? And for this definition of revolution I shall appeal to the etymology of the word: to revolve, to roll back (the shutters, perhaps?):
1) Make the people at the top aware of the existence of a problem. No bread you say? Let them eat cake...
2) Cause a commotion with the people in the middle that cannot be ignored, which means we cannot flick past it in the Sunday Supplement: and suddenly EverydaySexism means #YesAllWomen.
3) Let the people at the bottom know that it does matter, and it is shit and it doesn't have to be like this...
4) Revolution.
Or perhaps (and this is my vain hope) you can make something that contains enough for all four to happen, quietly and personally. Perhaps you can make something that enables one person to be shocked that nice men rape, and another to see that they can do something to effect change. I sincerely hope so, because that's what I'm spending my summer attempting to do.
David Sillito reports for the BBC:
"During his trial prosecutors said Harris was a "Jekyll and Hyde" character who took advantage of his fame."
Jane Peel talks of Harris': 'Dark side revealed under court's spotlight'.
I find this gothic language unhelpful: it's another way of making abusers 'other', another way of pretending this sort of thing is down to a few objectionable individuals, rather than something our culture facilitates. It was the same with the Elliot Rodger case: a kid declares his hatred for women because not one of us had offered ourselves to him, and he goes out and shoots at people, killing six. However the news stories are of a 'virgin killer' (like that explains anything) or even more worryingly fixated on his asperges as a means of discounting the misogynistic intent of his attacks.
If you listen very carefully you can hear the thrumming bass line beneath this kind of reporting 'notallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmen...'
Thing is, it's much more terrifying than that: you don't have to be a monster to be an abuser, you just have to decide to do it.
On the other end of the spectrum we have Charles Saatchi, pictured throttling his then wife at a ritzy London restaurant, now hosting artistic depictions of said assault on his company's website: enacting that very capitalist tactic of absorbing the opposition in order to smother it. And if there's one thing Mr Saatchi knows, it's the role of buying and selling in defining an artefact's cultural worth.
I'm not for a second implying that the acts perpetrated by Harris, Rodger, Saatchi and their fellow abusers aren't monstrous, but I am also saying: 'nice' men harrass, groom, molest, hit, strangle, manipulate, assault: nice men rape.
I've been thinking a lot about shocking truths supposedly 'hidden' in plain sight. I've written a show that is partly about how we only see what we are pre-disposed to see. It's a show about how our misogynistic culture plays out in our intimate relationships. It's also a show about Pick up Artist forums. For the uninitiated: the Pick up Artist industry teaches men techniques and behaviours to employ in picking up women. Despite the fact that these techniques are often highly reductive, predatory and manipulative, PUAs are largely written off as losers who can't pick up girls (sad little monsters). These have spawned reactionary 'anti-PUA' sites which refute the notion that men should have to use techniques or behaviours to get sex from women: not because these techniques and behaviours are often highly reductive, predatory and manipulative, but because women are only good for etc etc (shouty scary monsters). Seen in this context Rodger's actions are the logical end game for misogyny.
'notallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmennotallmen...'
Recently a very wise and very dear friend accused me of making 'middle class' art. As I baulked at this over my g'n't it clarified something for me about where I'm positioning this piece, and the media's infinite ability to be shocked by revelations of another nice man we all trusted before putting him in with all the other monsters...
Discounting is an unconscious minimisation or exaggeration of circumstance, relating to the self, others or a shared reality.
There are four accumulative levels of discounting:
1) The existence of a problem: nice men don't rape
2) The significance of a problem: ok, nice men do rape but it doesn't affect me
3) The possibility of change: ok, nice men do rape, this is bad for everybody but what can we do, it's the way they're wired, or something.
4) Our personal ability to effect change: ok, nice men do rape, this is bad for everybody, the ability to decide what we do with who we are is what makes us human, so I'm going to...
My answer to that last one was to write my show.
I've had to graciously concede that I'm not making proletariat revolutionary art. In fact, it's worse than what my dear, wise friend suspected, I might even be making art for the ruling classes. I wonder whether the four levels of discounting are also mirrored in how to make 'revolutionary' art according to our class system? And for this definition of revolution I shall appeal to the etymology of the word: to revolve, to roll back (the shutters, perhaps?):
1) Make the people at the top aware of the existence of a problem. No bread you say? Let them eat cake...
2) Cause a commotion with the people in the middle that cannot be ignored, which means we cannot flick past it in the Sunday Supplement: and suddenly EverydaySexism means #YesAllWomen.
3) Let the people at the bottom know that it does matter, and it is shit and it doesn't have to be like this...
4) Revolution.
Or perhaps (and this is my vain hope) you can make something that contains enough for all four to happen, quietly and personally. Perhaps you can make something that enables one person to be shocked that nice men rape, and another to see that they can do something to effect change. I sincerely hope so, because that's what I'm spending my summer attempting to do.
Labels:
abuse,
discounting,
feminism,
harris,
monsters,
rape,
revolution,
rodger,
saatchi,
theatre
Sunday, 13 April 2014
Great Aunt Joan
She wasn't
religious, or married and had no children. She worked and travelled, and
delighted in new discoveries. She went her own way. She was small and steadfast
and strong; and her strength has become mine: galvanised by the way she lived. She
was witty and wise, and I will miss her. I already miss her.
We watched The King’s Speech one Christmas, which
she enjoyed ‘although, I don’t actually remember the speech they’re all going
on about. But then we were being evacuated at the time, so we had other things
on our mind.’ She remembered singing ‘Hark the Herald Angels Sing, Mrs
Simpson’s pinched our King’.
She went on
to college and graduated as a teacher to deaf children. It was
strictly forbidden at that time to use sign or even gesticulate too much so
that children were forced to learn to lip-read, and she learnt to teach with
her hands in her pockets.
She stayed
curious and captivated by learning her whole life. There was hardly a time when
she wasn't on a course, whether restoring Ancient pottery or reading Modern
literature 'not really my period, I think I shall stick with my 18th century, I
know all of them.'
She was
stoic and private but also acutely astute and social.
Our last
conversation before she went into hospital was about the trouble she was having
with her iPad, which she had bought because 'as far as I can tell, if you're
not on the email you may as well be dead'.
She had a
smile that made her whole face turn upwards towards her eyes. Her laugh was
simultaneously generous and knowing: a gleeful acknowledgement of ‘yes, I see
what you did there’.
The last
time I saw her was at the theatre, she had come to see me perform. At the top
of the show we asked the audience to make little plasticine protestors and placards
(it was a show about activism). Aunt Joan was not going to be rushed. ‘I don’t
like all this pressure’ she declared to anyone attempting to badger her. I made
a point of reading the placard she had given her protestor ‘No Bullying.’
She took
herself to hospital during her first heart attack. On the bus. I went to
see her in hospital and when I asked her what she wanted from her flat she
replied 'Reading material. There's a copy of The Odyssey in the bookcase, bring
that'. I laughed and asked if she wanted anything a bit lighter. 'Now's as good
a time as any for Homer, don't you think?' came the reply.
I find
myself wanting to use the word ‘delight’ over and over again. She delighted,
brought delight, was delightful. She took
pleasure, unapologetically. And was equally nonplussed about not going along
with anything she didn’t want to. ‘We’re going for a walk in town Aunt Joan,
fancy it?’ [Great Aunt Joan peers at the blizzard outside the window]. ‘No
thank you.’ [Turns the page of her book, looks up, smiles].
She was
born in Kennington, but for as long as I have known her she lived in Highgate.
In a little crows nest of a flat at the top of the hill, on a clear day you
could see the Eye winking from the Thames. She loved living in Highgate.
‘Victoria Wood lives in Highgate, sometimes you’ll see her out and about but
nobody bothers her.’ When I lived in Muswell Hill, we would meet for lunch. She
didn’t drink much anymore, ‘that’s the thing about getting old, you can’t do as
many of the things you enjoy. But you must
have a glass of wine, and I shall take pleasure from yours.’
She
couldn’t drink proper coffee anymore either, but didn’t count instant ‘which is
more of a coffee flavoured drink’.
‘Was it the
years of drinking too much coffee when you were teaching that has stopped you
drinking now?’
‘Yes’ and
then after a pause ‘and all the gin’.
Have I said
she was small? She was the size of a grande latte, which meant losing her in a
crowd was almost guaranteed. I turned around for one minute in the British
Museum, and that was it, she’d disappeared. ‘I don’t much like that photograph
taken with your father, your Gran and I look like a couple of smurfs.’
But she was
also a giant. If you try and follow her footsteps now you will see, by a trick
of perspective, that in fact you can never span the full breadth and length of
the imprint she left on the earth.
One of
the last voicemails she left me was in typical Great Aunt Joan form. She didn’t
want to make a fuss ‘we’ll revert to Plan A, I’ll give you a wave and then
disappear.’
And then last week, she died. Suddenly, and without fuss, she disappeared.
And then last week, she died. Suddenly, and without fuss, she disappeared.
There is a
time for many words, and there is also a time for sleep.
- Homer, The Odyssey.
On you
go Great Aunt Joan; I’m following right behind you, with my face turned upward
to the sky.
Wednesday, 19 March 2014
Going off-script: real life ad-libbing.
In the show
I’m currently touring we open by asking members of the audience to make a
plasticine version of themselves as they enter the theatre. Last night in
Alnwick a gentleman came up to me during this initial pre-amble to protest that
he ‘comes to the theatre to be entertained by the performers and not the other
way around’. On leaving he let it be known that he still prefers ‘plays with a
script’, which we took as a gratifying compliment. Thing is, we do have a script, but we’ve also got
carte blanche to meander from it according to whatever is happening in the room
during each performance: heckling, phone calls, stage invasion - all actions
are gleefully incorporated into the show. We’ve done our jobs well when even
the scripted bits feel as if we’re improvising.
Yet again I
find myself comparing this experience to the theory around life scripts. This
weekend on my psychotherapy course we explored our own life scripts [meaningful face]. The psychotherapeutic
counselors among you will be familiar with the ‘this is your life as a play’
exercise, for the uninitiated: essentially, you imagine your life as a play.
To envision
the First Act of our life play we are led by the course tutor to imagine the
stage onto which our life is set. What kind of play are we watching? Who are
the main characters? What is the atmosphere? Act One ends with the beginning of
adolescence.
The theatre
maker in me was already on guard for any Chekhovian weaponry adorning the
flats. (Anton Chekhov’s remark about playwriting that ‘if there’s a gun hanging
on the wall in Act One, it must be fired before the end of Act Three’ is one of
the oft quoted golden rules for making theatre, along with Aristotle wanging on
about time, and if you’re going to tour a show, three is the biggest cast you
can fit in a van). Of course because life scripts are by definition
‘unconscious’ it might not have helped the exercise that I was cognitively
analyzing my life script with such professional interest. I found myself
resisting the reflex to imagine a proscenium arch stage with obligatory red
velvet curtains, yet despite the fact that I can count on one hand the times I
have performed on such stages in my career, this stereotype is what sprung to
mind when asked to ‘imagine a stage’. In a small way this is an example of how
life scripts work: an inherited idea with which, despite present-day
resistance, we are compelled to comply.
The Second
Act of our life plays took us up to present day. After the fight-dance
choreography item of my late adolescence I found myself turning to the box and
asking for the house lights to be switched on and the red velvet curtains taken
down. I stood on the lip of the stage, conscious of being higher than the
stalls and not wanting to be, conscious of ‘being in a play’ and not wanting to
be. As we took a break to notice what we had conjured in our respective
life-plays my mind wandered as I wondered about the connection between my
desire to break the fourth wall in both my ‘life play’ and work in general.
So much of
the theatre being made now that excites and engages me enacts this
deconstruction of inherited convention. The artists I look up to are the ones
you don’t literally look up to from the stalls – they’re on the threshing floor
with you, in this moment, in the same room, and they’re talking to you. Not yesterday’s audience, not the
audience they imagined in rehearsals, but the living-breathing-right-here-now
audience. In a sense, the theatre I’m interested in making is theatre that is
interested in breaking it’s own inherited script.
I’m
thinking of Steiner’s assertion that life script is ‘a life plan which is rigid
and unchangeable. Like the lines of a play, a life plan expects to be followed
word by word from beginning to end and allows for little improvisation. A
script is written by somebody else and like actors in a play we feel bound by
ourselves and others to act the part to the bitter or happy ending’ (Steiner C,
1979, Healing Alcholism).
Far be it
for me to contradict the man who brought us ‘Warm Fuzzies’ but there are plays
that allow for a bit more than ‘a little improvisation’, in fact there are
plays that allow some of the script to be created live each night. I happen to
be in one. I concede the ending is always (necessarily) the same, and to that
extent it is absolutely scripted, however the care taken to make it feel like it might not be, speaks to the
desire to ‘break script’ and act according to the moment, to be truly ‘live’.
It is pleasing that the same language when applied to breaking life scripts
describes people who are wholly a-live.
To imagine
one’s Third Act is to contemplate the type of ending you feel your life play is
heading toward. ‘Ah’, I thought, as I returned to the mind-theatre I had just
flattened at the end of Act Two, what to do now then? Make it about the
audience, I supposed. Let some of the audience onstage. Go and sit amongst the
others. ‘What happens next?’ Well I have no idea - it entirely depends on who
else is in the room. ‘How does it end?’ Well I guess I’ll leave, at ground
level, probably through a fire exit, I might afford myself a Hollywood-esque
backward glance, perhaps I’ll sight a space once called ‘a stage’ filled with
people getting on with stuff. Maybe I’ll have played a part in starting that.
[Curtain]
Labels:
Berne,
Chekhov,
improvising,
life script,
play,
psychotherapy,
Steiner,
theatre
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

